Skip to main content

Who discovered water on moon first NASA or ISRO?




50 years ago Neil Armstrong had set his foot on the moon, becoming the first human to step on the moon. The curiosity in human beings about discovering things beyond Earth has resulted in numerous space missions.


Mission commander Neil Armstrong took this photograph with a 70mm lunar surface camera, in frame Astronaut Buzz Aldrin. Image credit-NASA


Surprisingly, NASA on its own failed 12 times before completing an orbital mission called Ranger 7 in 1964. Apollo 11 in 1969 was the first crew landing mission on the moon.

(Image credit: NASA)

ISRO, on the other hand, was formed in 1962 as INCOSPAR (The Indian National Committee for Space Research) with urging scientist Vikram Sarabhai. In 1969 under the tenure of Prime Minister of India Jawaharlal Nehru INCOSPAR became ISRO.



Indian Space Research Organisation is managed by the Department of Space which directly reports to the Prime Minister of India.
As compared to NASA, ISRO launched its first satellite Aaryabhatta in 1975 whereas in 1969 NASA was the one to land humans on the moon.

ISRO started growing fast under DOS. It launched various satellites and rockets (launch vehicles).

ISRO launched its first mission in lunar probe Chandrayaan in Oct 2008. At first, Chandrayaan only had lunar orbiter in its mission. Orbiter's main objective was to design and develop a 3D atlas of both near and far areas of the moon.






APJ Abdul Kalam’s vision

A Moon Impact Probe (MIP) was added which was a product of late former President of India APJ Abdul Kalam’s vision. He suggested that since Chandrayaan orbiter was already going near to the moon, using a Moon Impact Probe can contribute more to the mission.




APJ Abdul Kalam’s political stake on this was

“If this probe was done, India could always stake a claim to a portion of the moon”

“No nation can claim the moon as its own. The resources of the moon should be common property to all”
                                                               -  Dr A. P. J. Abdul Kalam

   Late Former Former President of India





Moon Impact Probe was designed to crash land on the moon surface after separating from Chandryaan.




MIP, after separation continuously sent data to Chandryaan orbital for 25mins, after which it crash-landed on 14 Nov 2008 at speed of 6100km/hr. MIP crashed Shackleton crater at the lunar south pole. The location of the impact on the moon was named Jawahar point.
MIP crash-landed hard releasing underground matter which was analyzed by the orbiter for discovering the presence of water ice on the moon.



So who did it first NASA or ISRO?

NASA had contributed 2 instruments to Chandrayaan mission, from which was Moon Mineralogy Mapper (M3). It was designed to provide high resolution spatial and spectral maps of the entire moon surface and analyzing minerals present.

On September 24, 2009, Science magazine reported NASA Mapper on Chandrayaan-1 detected water on the moon.

On September 25, 2009, ISRO MIP also reported to discover water on the moon just before the impact and this was discovered before NASA Mapper.


So ISRO MIP discovered water on moon surface making India the first country to find water on the moon.

This announcement was not made until NASA confirmed it.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

How our Ganapati Bappa, “Remover of obstacles”, will help us clean our rivers, lakes & sea?

    Lord Ganesha is one of the most revered deities in Hinduism. He is the lord of success, destroyer of evils and remover of obstacles. He is worshipped at the beginning of a ceremony or a rite to ensure that the ceremony advances smoothly without any obstacles. How lord Ganesha got the title of “the remover of obstacles”? Lord Vishnu the preserver of the universe was getting married and all the Gods and Goddesses residing in the Swarg Loka were invited including Lord Ganesha. But all the deities tricked Lord Ganesha into guarding the Swarg Loka while others left for the wedding. Narad Muni being his usual self informed Lord Ganesha that he was tricked into guarding the Swarg Loka as all the other Gods and Goddesses were embarrassed by his eating habits and physical appearance. Eventually Lord Ganesha was furious and decided to teach them a lesson. In his rage, he sent Gajasur who dug up the roads stopping the convoy. All the Gods and Goddesses tried to...

What went wrong in Chandrayaan-2 landing? How did NASA land humans on Moon?

ISRO used a remote-controlled system to communicate and command Chandryaan-2. Electromagnetic waves are used to communicate in space as they can travel through a vacuum. There are various factors by which can these electromagnetic waves can get disturbed. The same happened with Chandryaan-2, orbiter lost connection with Vikram lander. Apollo 11 mission, Spacecraft Saturn V had various modules in it. The lunar module on top carried a service module and command module. In the final earth orbit, the service module fires the engine and rotates 180 degrees. It attached itself to the lunar module and firing engines for a translunar injection heading towards the moon. Next 3 days Apollo travelled to the moon final getting in lunar orbit by moons gravity. All three astronauts separate themselves and slowly start descending the Eagle towards the lunar surface. Eagle finally landed on the lunar surface on July 24, 1969. If we notic...